Are lots of choices helping or hurting your sales?
Thursday, March 24th, 2011
Choices. People just love choices. Choices present options, opportunities for customization, and lots of reasons to try or buy. Right?
I was in meeting recently, reviewing competitive intelligence for a very cluttered category. Among the findings was the abundance of features the different competitors offered consumers. And having pored through so many competitors with so many choices, I found myself in the shoes of their shopper, completely overwhelmed and uncertain which I would personally choose.
Immediately, I thought: “jam!” Not as in “brain jammed by too many options,” but rather, strawberry, grape, and other flavors. Specifically, a study I recalled that was conducted by a Columbia University professor, a California gourmet market, and a premium jam maker.
In the study, a sampling booth set up in a gourmet market enabled consumers to try different types of one brand of jam. Every few hours the assortment was changed between a larger set of flavors and a smaller set: twenty-four different flavors, to just six.
On average, consumers tasted at least two kinds of jam, and everyone received a dollar off coupon to purchase. But what ultimately drove sales stemmed from the number of choices the consumers were presented. Sixty percent of the shoppers were drawn to the large assortment, while only 40 percent stopped by the small one. But when it came to actually making a purchase, all those choices actually paralyzed the consumers. Thirty percent of the people who had sampled from the small assortment decided to buy jam, while only 3 percent of those consumers who had to choose from the two dozen different jams purchased a jar.
Similar studies have been done around chocolate, 401k plans, and speed dating, all with similar results. A large assortment of choices may attract attention, but when it comes to actually making a choice and buying, it’s distracting. Additional research also concluded that ultimately, when a consumer does make a choice from among many, he or she is more likely to feel less satisfied, less happy with the choice and even insecure, asking “did I make the right selection?” In other words, walking away with a negative experience.
So often we see brands, clients and even agency people thinking that more is more. Give them choices, give them options, and let them choose! But in the end, providing a focused, more streamlined offering leads to “happiness” and ultimately, a sale – whether it’s features and functions, or product benefits, or even creative choices.
(Source: New York Times, “Too Many Choices: A Problem That Can Paralyze,” Alina Tungend, February 26, 2010)

Last week, marketers from all around the tri-state area converged in New Jersey at our Fuel for Thought conference to learn, share experiences and develop ideas to get a handle on social media marketing. There’s a lot we covered/learned from each session and we’ll be sharing key highlights and materials here on our blog.


![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=a687b4d9-0876-4903-a7ae-61687db4db74)

